What material for short pile rug: wool or synthetic?

by
When you buy through links on our site, “As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases."
✔ Fact Checked by Fact Checker
5/5 - (2 votes)

Choosing the material for a short pile rug is one of the most important decisions when decorating a bedroom, living room, or dining room in our home. In this article, we will compare two popular materials: wool and synthetic fibers.

What material to choose for a short pile rug?

short pile rug
Short pile rug

Both have advantages and disadvantages and understanding them is key to making the right decision when choosing a rug suitable for our daily lives.

Advantages and disadvantages of wool rugs

Wool is a natural material spun with wool strands obtained from shearing sheep, and it has been used for centuries to make wool rugs, clothing, and fabrics. Some of the main advantages of wool rugs are:

  • Resistance to use or abrasion: wool fibers have good resistance to use, and their fibers have the property of resilience; that is, they have elasticity to return to their initial state and reduce the typical caking or crushing of the fibers of the carpets.
  • Thermal and acoustic insulation: wool is a highly insulating material that prevents the cold or heat outside from affecting our room and reduces noise inside and outside our home.
  • Fire retardant: Wool fibers perform well against fire since they generally do not spread the flame.
  • Regulates humidity: thanks to its hygrothermal properties, it helps regulate environmental humidity, increases interior comfort, and even reduces static electricity.
  • It is an organic fiber; that is, it is ecological and can even be reused or recycled.
  • It is soft to the touch, increasing comfort and convenience in use areas such as living rooms, dressing rooms, or bedrooms.
  • Wool rugs are much more durable than those made of synthetic fibers. Even with good maintenance and conservation, they can last for decades—in some cases, even centuries!

Although, like almost all aspects of life, it also has a series of characteristics that work against it. Its drawbacks would be:

  • Early in the life of rugs, lint may occur due to rubbing or wear. This is because since wool threads are discontinuous fibers (with a limited length) formed from smaller strands, those strands that are not well knotted to the base of the carpet are the ones that become loose little by little. Little due to friction and daily use. When joined together, these strands form the typical fluff in new wool rugs. These lint are only an aesthetic nuisance during the first weeks of use, as they do not affect the durability or resistance of the carpet.
  • As natural fibers, they are more porous than synthetic fibers, so cleaning can be a little more complex since liquid stains can penetrate a little deeper into the thread. Still, in general, most stains can be cleaned without problem with neutral, soapy products, vinegar, or ammonia.
  • The cost of purchasing a wool rug is generally higher than that of a synthetic fiber rug. However, the amortization of the carpet should really be assessed according to its durability.

Advantages and disadvantages of synthetic carpets

The most commonly used synthetic fiber rugs in carpets are made of materials such as PVC, polypropylene, polyamide (or nylon), and polyester. In addition, recently recycled synthetic fibers have been manufactured from nylon, such as ECONYL, or PET plastic bottles.

Thanks to new technologies and innovation in the thread manufacturing industry, a wide variety of synthetic fibers are being obtained, with different qualities and properties associated with each composition.

In general, it is cheaper than natural fibers since its manufacturing method can optimize the entire industrial process and reduce costs. In addition, the raw material is much easier to obtain than natural fiber.

Among its main advantages, in general, we can find:

  • They are slightly porous fibers, so they are more resistant to dirt and can be cleaned more easily.
  • They are suitable for outdoor use, depending on the fiber, as they can resist sunlight and water.
  • Depending on the composition, some are more or less resistant to use, so they can be used even in very high-traffic areas.
  • Its appearance can be matte, satin, or gloss, achieving different aspects with the same type of fiber in the same rug, such as the well-known water effect.
  • Depending on the quality of the fiber, you can get rugs that are very soft to the touch, even with a touch similar to silk.
  • Synthetic fibers, simply because they are artificial, are not good friends with possible insects, mites, etc. Therefore, they cannot survive if they are deposited on carpets (with proper maintenance to eliminate organic remains that may fall on the carpet).
  • Thanks to their easy maintenance, they are one of the most chosen options for rugs in children’s areas or with pets.

On the other hand, some of the disadvantages that we can find in short-pile synthetic fiber carpets are:

  • They do not have good resistance to crushing. Over time, the fibers can become matted earlier than in wool rugs. To avoid this, it is best to carry out regular and adequate maintenance. We can even go to a professional cleaning service every 3 or 6 months, depending on the use to which we subject the carpet.
  • Its appearance is more elegant and comfortable than natural rugs.
  • Although recycled fibers are increasingly being used to weave carpets, they are still a minority, so in general, synthetic fiber carpets are still not as environmentally friendly as natural fiber carpets.
  • Synthetic fibers are not as insulating as wool fibers, so comfort is inferior to a natural fiber rug.

Now that we know the advantages and disadvantages of each material, what other factors can we consider when choosing our wool or synthetic short pile rug? As a list, we have prepared a series of questions that will help us decide on the most appropriate rug for our needs:

What size will the rug be?

Would we like a rug in solid colors or with patterns: classic, modern, ethnic, etc.?

Will we place the rug in a busy or low-traffic place?

Do we have an approximate budget for purchasing the rug?

Do we prefer that the carpet be easy to clean, or do we give more priority to quality and comfort?

Choosing the right rug for our needs can be a complex decision. Still, by being clear about the advantages and disadvantages of each material, the answers to the previous questions, and with the help of professionals from your rug store, you will surely be able to find the right one. The rug that best fits your home and is totally satisfying.